There are no nonzero integer solutions to x4
+ y4 = z4
001
|
Assume x4 + y4 = z4,
where x, y and z are nonzero integers.
|
002
|
Letting w = z2, we have x4 + y4
= w2.
|
003
|
Dividing out any common factors, there exists an X,
Y, and W such that X4 + Y4 = W2 in which X,
Y, and W are relatively prime.
|
004
|
Then (X2)2 + (Y2)2
= W2
|
005
|
Then there exists a Pythagorean solution for (X2)2
+ (Y2)2 = W2, which is X2 = p2
– q2, Y2 = 2pq, and W = p2 + q2,
where p, q and X are relatively prime.
|
006
|
Then there also exists a second Pythagorean solution
for X2 = p2 – q2, which is X = m2
– n2, p = m2 + n2, and q = 2mn, where m and
n are relatively prime.
|
007
|
Assume p and m are not relatively prime:
|
008
|
Then p = fP and m = fM
|
009
|
And n is also divisible by f since n2
= p – m2 = fP – (fM)2 = fP – f2M2
= f(P – fM2)
|
010
|
Then n and m have a common factor f.
|
011
|
But this contradicts that m and n are
relatively prime.
|
012
|
So p and m are relatively prime.
|
013
|
Assume p and n are not relatively prime:
|
014
|
Then p = fP and n = fN
|
015
|
And m is also divisible by f since m2
= p + n2 = fP + (fN)2 = fP + f2N2
= f(P + fN2)
|
016
|
Then n and m have a common factor f.
|
017
|
But this contradicts that m and n are
relatively prime.
|
018
|
So p and n are relatively prime.
|
019
|
Therefore, since m and n are relatively prime, and p
and m are relatively prime, and p and n are relatively prime, that means p,
m, and n are relatively prime.
|
020
|
Now Y2
= 4pmn, because Y2 = 2pq = 2p(2mn) = 4pmn.
|
021
|
Since Y2 = 4pmn and p, m, and n are
relatively prime, p, m, and n are squares, so p = w’2, m = x’2,
and n = y’2
|
022
|
Substituting into p = m2 + n2,
we have w’2 = (x’2)2 + (y’2)2,
or x’4 + y’4 = w’2.
|
023
|
Now x’ < w since x’ is a factor of m which is a
factor of q which (because W = p2 + q2) is less than W
which a factor of w
|
024
|
And y’ < w since y’ is a factor of n which is a
factor of q which (because W = p2 + q2) is also less
than W which is a factor of w
|
025
|
And w’ < w since w’ is a factor of p which
(because W = p2 + q2) is also less than W which is a
factor of w
|
026
|
So there exists integers x’, y’, and w’ such that x’4
+ y’4 = w’2 and 1 ≤ x’ < w, 1 ≤ y’ < w, and 1 ≤
w’ < w.
|
027
|
Therefore, if x4 + y4 = w2,
there must exist other positive integers x’, y’, w’ such that 1 ≤ x’ < w,
1 ≤ y’ < w, and 1 < w’ < w in which x’4 + y’4
= w’2.
|
028
|
But we can use the same argument to prove the
existence of more positive integers x”, y”, w” such that 1 ≤ x” < w’, 1 ≤
y” < w’, and 1 < w” < w’ in which x”4 + y”4 =
w”2, and another x’”, y’”, w’”, and so on, so we have a
contradiction by the method of infinite descent.
|
029
|
Therefore, there are no nonzero integer solutions to
x4 + y4 = z4.
|
Q.E.D.
No comments:
Post a Comment